🇨🇦 SILVER Joseph · CANADA

81rank
-15.6Butler · 224 bds
-0.07per board
±4.6swing
-0.42vs par /bd · #86/127
+0.05adjusted /bd
Butler per round: -34.3 -22.6 -22.1 5.1 -18.7 -13.4 23 26.4 15.4 -14.5 9.3 48.5 6 -23.7by round

vs par split: bidding -0.51 · play +0.05

Strength of schedule: opponents averaged +0.12/bd (a tough draw) → opponent-adjusted +0.05/bd

Card play — on target: opening leads 75.0% #92 of 126 · declarer play 81.7% #20 of 126 · defence 88.9% #28 of 127

Card play by contract type — on target
vs NTvs a suit
Opening leads58.3% (12)82.1% (28)
Declarer play80.8% (26)82.1% (56)
Defence71.0% (31)97.1% (68)

Opening leads by suit led: ♠ 58.3% (12) · ♥ 81.8% (11) · ♦ 88.9% (9) · ♣ 75.0% (8)

vs par by strain: NT -1.31 (68) · a suit -0.05 (155)

vs par by level: part-score -0.20 (71) · game -0.05 (138) · slam -5.43 (14)

By role: declaring -0.11/bd (-2.54 vs par · 124) · defending -0.02/bd (+2.21 vs par · 100)

By vulnerability: vulnerable -0.30/bd (-1.19 vs par · 112) · not vulnerable +0.16/bd (+0.35 vs par · 112)

By round↑ top

RoundPartnerOpponentsRoomBdsButlerAvgvs par
Round 1J.CarruthersH.Stalzer – F.TerraneoOpen16-34.3-2.14-1.00
Round 3J.CarruthersP.O'Briain – M.O'BriainClosed16-22.6-1.41-2.00
Round 4J.CarruthersP.Eliasson – J.OstbergClosed16-22.1-1.38-1.75
Round 6J.CarruthersM.Zwerling – M.TolliverClosed16+5.1+0.32+0.44
Round 8J.CarruthersA.Sadhu – B.DasClosed16-18.7-1.17+1.44
Round 9J.CarruthersM.Rosenberg – Z.MahmoodClosed16-13.4-0.84-0.25
Round 10J.CarruthersP.Cury – E.ZahrClosed16+23.0+1.44-1.31
Round 11J.CarruthersE.La Rovere – O.CorreaClosed16+26.4+1.65-0.81
Round 13J.CarruthersC.Baert – M.FoucherClosed16+15.4+0.96+0.44
Round 14J.CarruthersD.Sacul – B.PoliiOpen16-14.5-0.91+0.94
Round 17J.CarruthersA.Askalani – A.WahdanClosed16+9.3+0.58-1.50
Round 18J.CarruthersM.Mazhar – K.IbrahimClosed16+48.5+3.03+3.50
Round 19J.CarruthersK.Yamada – T.ImakuraOpen16+6.0+0.38-2.75
Round 21J.CarruthersJ.Holland – G.HallbergOpen16-23.7-1.48-1.25

Every board — best Butler first↑ top

vs par = IMPs this pair scored above (+) or below (−) the board’s double-dummy par — what bidding and play (theirs and the opponents’) added or gave away against perfect play.

ButlerRoundOpponentsBdContractLeadResvs par
+12.2Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL153NT♣8=+12
+11.0Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE55♠♣K-1+11
+10.7Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN235♥x♠K-3+5
+10.0Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE313NT♠J-3+12
+9.9Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE184♠♦4=+0
+9.1Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN53NT♥2=+10
+8.5Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE246♠♣K=+5
+8.3Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE34♠♦A-3+12
+7.9Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN275♥x♦A=+8
+7.6Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL35♣♦A=-2
+7.2Round 6🇺🇸 USA2196♥♠K-1+13
+7.2Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND163NT♠5+1+7
+7.0Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN244♠x♣7-2+9
+6.9Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND13♣x♣A-2+9
+6.7Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN74♥♦8=+10
+6.2Round 9🇺🇸 USA113NT♥Q-2+6
+6.2Round 9🇺🇸 USA152♥♠A-2+3
+6.0Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL45♥x♠3=+5
+5.9Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND44♠♦9+1+4
+5.9Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA215♣♠3-1+10
+5.7Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND134♠♥K+2-3
+5.6Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN14♥♦J-2+5
+5.3Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT95♦♠4+1-13
+5.2Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT124♥♦2-1+12
+5.1Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT82♠♣J+2+7
+5.0Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL144♥♣J+1+1
+4.9Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN173♥♠K-1+9
+4.9Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN316NT♠4=+1
+4.8Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA253♥♦10=+0
+4.6Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE114♥♣K=-1
+4.6Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN205♠♥6-2+8
+4.4Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND63♣♦K-1+12
+4.3Round 6🇺🇸 USA2284♥♠5=+0
+4.1Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE62♠♦8+1+8
+4.0Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT34♠♥9=+0
+3.9Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE124♥♠Q-2+5
+3.3Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA283NT♣4+1-13
+3.2Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL12♠♥8=-1
+3.2Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND72♣♠10+2+10
+3.1Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE283NT♠J+2+0
+3.1Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA275♣♠K-1+5
+3.1Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN105♥♦A=+0
+3.0Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA26♥♦4=-13
+3.0Round 6🇺🇸 USA2292♠♣4+1+0
+3.0Round 9🇺🇸 USA1163♦-2+5
+3.0Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE91NT♠A-3+5
+3.0Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA233♠♦6=+12
+3.0Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN112♥♠J+2-6
+2.9Round 6🇺🇸 USA2183♥♦3=+1
+2.9Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN184♠♦2-1+5
+2.9Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN254♥♦3+3+2
+2.8Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN321NT♥8-4+0
+2.7Round 9🇺🇸 USA144♠♦J+1+0
+2.7Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA294♠♥Q=-1
+2.6Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA174♥♠3+1+14
+2.6Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN282♥♠7=+0
+2.5Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE211♠♥4+3+6
+2.5Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE301NT♠A-3+1
+2.5Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL123NT♥J+1+1
+2.5Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE43NT♦6+2+2
+2.5Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE74♠♦7+1+1
+2.5Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE144♥♠3-2+6
+2.3Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA63NT♠J-1+0
+2.3Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA213♣♦2+1+1
+2.2Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN293♠♣A+1-1
+2.1Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL64♠♥Q+2+1
+2.1Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA302♠♥A-1+8
+2.1Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND132♠♠3=+1
+2.0Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA152♥♦9+1+0
+2.0Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND124♠♦3-1+5
+2.0Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL93NT♥4=+0
+1.9Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN64♥♦Q=-1
+1.8Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT54♠♦A=+0
+1.8Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN291NT♣2=+0
+1.8Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN304♥♠5-1+5
+1.6Round 6🇺🇸 USA2263NT♥7+2+0
+1.6Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL163NT♠5+2+0
+1.6Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN144♠♣J+3-14
+1.5Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA194♥♠6+1+13
+1.5Round 9🇺🇸 USA193NT♠A+2+2
+1.4Round 6🇺🇸 USA2254♠♦A-1+9
+1.3Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN252♥♠J+1+0
+1.2Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN213NT♥8+3+3
+1.2Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA313NT♦5+2+1
+1.2Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE272♥♠8-1+2
+1.2Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT114♠♥J=+0
+1.2Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN212NT♦3+1+6
+1.1Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA184♥♣3=+3
+1.0Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND23NT♣10+2-11
+1.0Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND81NT♥2+2+0
+1.0Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA323NT♠Q=+2
+1.0Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT145♣♠J+1+0
+1.0Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND93♦♣8-2+1
+0.9Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND64♥♠K+1+1
+0.9Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL24♠♦K+2-12
+0.9Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT44♠x♥A-1+0
+0.9Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND43NT♥3=+0
+0.8Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN283NT♥6+1+1
+0.8Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA304♥♣K=+1
+0.8Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN164♥♣K=+0
+0.7Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA203♦♥3-1+5
+0.7Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE153NT♦4+4-12
+0.7Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN33NT♦2+3-11
+0.6Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA84♠♥10+1+0
+0.6Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND92NT♥Q-2+6
+0.5Round 6🇺🇸 USA2213NT♥9=+3
+0.5Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE14♠♥K+1+0
+0.5Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT62♠♥10-2-9
+0.5Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT73NT♦5+1+0
+0.3Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA33NT♦2=-2
+0.3Round 6🇺🇸 USA2241NT♥10-2+0
+0.3Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN24♠♥2=-1
+0.2Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN192♠♦3+1+0
+0.1Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA132♥♣J+1+0
+0.1Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN264♠♦Q-1+6
-0.0Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA174♥♦3+2+1
+0.0Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA294♥♠4+2+1
+0.0Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA324♠♦5=+13
+0.0Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE164♥♣K+1+0
-0.0Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA223NT♥5+2+1
+0.0Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN193NT♥4+1+0
-0.0Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN41NT♠J-2+2
-0.1Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA104♥♦J+3+17
-0.1Round 9🇺🇸 USA172♥♣Q+1+0
-0.2Round 6🇺🇸 USA2303NT♣7+2+0
-0.2Round 6🇺🇸 USA231Pass+3
-0.3Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA93NT♣K+1+13
-0.3Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE253NT♠5-1-5
-0.3Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND114♦♥K-1-2
-0.4Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE173♣♠6=-7
-0.4Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT14♥♠Q+1+0
-0.5Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE233♦♠J=-1
-0.6Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA54♥♦K+1+0
-0.6Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN182♠♣K+2+6
-0.6Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN204♥♣2+2-17
-0.6Round 6🇺🇸 USA2272♠♠5+1-7
-0.7Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA244♥♣K=-3
-0.7Round 9🇺🇸 USA124♥♦4-1-4
-0.8Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND12♦♥10+1+0
-0.8Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA221NT♠3+2+10
-0.8Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA285♥x♠K-2-5
-0.9Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND154♥♦5+1+0
-0.9Round 9🇺🇸 USA1154♥♦Q+1+10
-1.0Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA254♠♥5+2+9
-1.0Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND103NT♦Q+1+1
-1.1Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN222♥♦2=+0
-1.1Round 9🇺🇸 USA1111NT♥2+3-1
-1.4Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE326NT♥Q+1-11
-1.4Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL105♠♣A-1+3
-1.6Round 6🇺🇸 USA2202♥♦Q+1+0
-1.6Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE203NT♦Q-2-13
-1.7Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN174♥♠J=-11
-1.7Round 9🇺🇸 USA182♠♠2+1+0
-1.7Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE222♠♦J=+0
-1.8Round 9🇺🇸 USA1142♥♥7-1-2
-1.8Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA202♦x♣A-3+11
-1.8Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT163♣♦10+2-10
-1.9Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA143NT♠5=+0
-1.9Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE294♠x♥Q-1-2
-1.9Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL83♠♥2+1-6
-1.9Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT103NT♦5+3-1
-2.0Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND144♥♣7-2-6
-2.0Round 6🇺🇸 USA2174♠♦K-1+2
-2.0Round 9🇺🇸 USA1123NT♠2=+0
-2.0Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL131NT♣5=-5
-2.0Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN225♥♦2=+4
-2.0Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN124♠♣K=+0
-2.0Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND83NT♠5+2+0
-2.1Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND153NT♠2-2-7
-2.2Round 9🇺🇸 USA134♠♣3=+0
-2.3Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND104♥♣J-2-2
-2.3Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT152♠♥9+3-6
-2.6Round 6🇺🇸 USA2233NT♥A-1-6
-2.7Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA242♥♣A+1+0
-2.8Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND54♥x♠A-2+5
-2.8Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN304♥♠Q=+0
-2.8Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL112♥♣6+3-6
-3.0Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN233♦♠5=-6
-3.0Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL72♦♠4+2+0
-3.1Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN92NT♥3+1-7
-3.2Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE194♠♥4=+0
-3.4Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA43NT♠5+2-2
-3.6Round 9🇺🇸 USA1133NT♣5=+1
-3.7Round 10🇨🇱 CHILE263NT♦A-2-8
-3.8Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN313♥♣2-2-9
-3.8Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT24♠x♥A-3+0
-3.9Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN82♠♦K=-5
-4.0Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE23♦♠K-1-10
-4.2Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND32♠♣Q-1-5
-4.2Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN243NT♦Q=+1
-4.2Round 6🇺🇸 USA2324♠♦J-3-6
-4.3Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND126♠♥Q=+0
-4.4Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA124♠♦K-1-6
-4.4Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA314♥x♣K-2-5
-4.5Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN133NT♠6+1-10
-4.6Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN322NT♥K+1-1
-4.7Round 6🇺🇸 USA2224♠♥2-1-5
-5.0Round 9🇺🇸 USA1103♥♦A+1-10
-5.5Round 4🇸🇪 SWEDEN277♥♥2=+0
-5.5Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE134♥♠K=+0
-5.5Round 18🇵🇰 PAKISTAN263NT♠Q-1-6
-5.6Round 11🇧🇷 BRAZIL53NTx♥9=-4
-5.9Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA116♥♠5=+0
-6.0Round 17🇪🇬 EGYPT134♠♥Q-3-4
-6.8Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA73NT♠5+3-3
-7.2Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE83NT♠10+1-7
-7.5Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA14♥♣7=-7
-7.6Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND166♦♠4=+0
-7.6Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND36♥♣Q-1-14
-8.5Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA185♠♥A-1-9
-8.5Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA263♠x♣K-2-8
-8.6Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA273NT♠Q-1-10
-9.0Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND115♠♥7-1-10
-9.1Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND146♠♦A-2-14
-9.2Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA261NT♠2-4-7
-9.4Round 14🇮🇩 INDONESIA193NT♥4+2-11
-10.1Round 3🇮🇪 IRELAND74♥♠Q-1-16
-11.3Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND23NT♥K-1-12
-11.5Round 13🇬🇵 GUADELOUPE106♥♣6-1-13
-11.7Round 1🇦🇹 AUSTRIA163NT♥K+1-13
-11.7Round 21🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 ENGLAND53♥x♣K-4-12
-12.9Round 8🇮🇳 INDIA233♣x♣3-4-11
-13.3Round 19🇯🇵 JAPAN156♣♠4-1-16
-13.9Round 9🇺🇸 USA166♥♦7-4-14